Comparison

Green Claims Directive vs EmpCo: what applies, and when

Last checked:

Two EU files, one topic, very different status. This page separates the law you must comply with from the proposal you only need to watch.

The short answer

The Green Claims Directive is a proposal the European Commission announced on 4 November 2026 that it will withdraw. EmpCo, Directive (EU) 2024/825, is adopted law: Member States had to transpose it by 27 March 2026 and apply their measures from 27 September 2026. Check national enactment and commencement. If you are planning campaigns or packaging today, plan around EmpCo.

Most teams meet these two files in the wrong order. The Green Claims Directive got the headlines, so it is the name people search for, while the rules that actually bite first arrived quietly inside an amendment to existing consumer law.

Side-by-side comparison

Comparison of the EmpCo Directive and the proposed Green Claims Directive
 EmpCo (2024/825)Green Claims Directive
Legal statusAdopted and in force at EU levelProposal; withdrawal announced 4 November 2026, due within six months
InstrumentDirective (EU) 2024/825Proposed directive on green claims (COM/2023/166)
What it changesAmends the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive (2005/29/EC) and the Consumer Rights Directive (2011/83/EU)Would create a separate substantiation and verification regime
Core mechanismProhibits listed practices, including generic claims, offsetting-based carbon neutrality and self-made labelsWould require evidence and third-party verification before an explicit claim is used
LabelsBans sustainability labels not based on a certification scheme or set by public authoritiesWould regulate new labelling schemes and their approval
Key datesTransposition 27 March 2026, applies 27 September 2026No application date; withdrawal listed in the Commission 2027 work programme
What to doCheck national measures; fix live claims and start packaging changes in parallelDo not plan for it; keep evidence files for EmpCo and existing consumer law

For the full list of practices EmpCo prohibits, see banned claims.

What is the Green Claims Directive?

The Green Claims Directive is a proposed EU directive on substantiating and communicating explicit environmental claims. It would require substantiation and independent verification of claims within its scope, subject to exclusions and exemptions, and regulate environmental labelling schemes. It has not been adopted as a directive.

In practice it is the evidence law. Where EmpCo names the claims you may not make, the Green Claims Directive would ask, before publication, what your claim is based on, how it was measured, whether the assessment covers the whole life cycle and who checked it.

Is the Green Claims Directive in force?

No. On 4 November 2026 the European Commission listed the proposal for withdrawal in Annex III of its 2027 work programme, stating it is unlikely to secure support in the Council within a reasonable timeframe. The Commission intends to withdraw it within six months; until the formal withdrawal, the proposal technically remains pending. It has no application date.

Status sources checked 16 November 2026: Commission work programme ↗ and official legislative procedure record ↗.

With withdrawal announced, any agency deck or supplier questionnaire quoting Green Claims Directive obligations and dates is out of date. Up-front verification will not become mandatory through this proposal, but you still need proof when a regulator or competitor asks. Prioritise national measures implementing EmpCo .

Which one should you plan around now?

Plan around the enacted national EmpCo measures in your markets. The EU application deadline was 27 September 2026, but national enactment and commencement need checking. Do not delay claims audits while waiting for the Green Claims proposal; the Commission announced its withdrawal on 4 November 2026, and evidence files remain essential under EmpCo and existing consumer law.

  1. 1. Inventory every environmental claim you make, per market and per channel.
  2. 2. Triage each claim against the EmpCo prohibitions using the claim checker.
  3. 3. Build a substantiation file for every claim you keep, to support it under applicable consumer law.
  4. 4. Sequence rewrites by lead time against the EmpCo timeline.

Common questions

What is the Green Claims Directive?
The Green Claims Directive is a proposed EU directive on substantiating and communicating explicit environmental claims. It would require substantiation and independent verification of claims within its scope, subject to exclusions and exemptions, and regulate environmental labelling schemes. It has not been adopted as a directive.
Is the Green Claims Directive in force?
No. On 4 November 2026 the European Commission listed the proposal for withdrawal in Annex III of its 2027 work programme, stating it is unlikely to secure support in the Council within a reasonable timeframe. The Commission intends to withdraw it within six months; until the formal withdrawal, the proposal technically remains pending. It has no application date.
What is the difference between EmpCo and the Green Claims Directive?
EmpCo bans specific misleading practices by amending existing EU consumer law; Member States had to apply their implementing measures from 27 September 2026. The Green Claims proposal would add an up-front substantiation and verification regime for explicit environmental claims. Confirm the applicable national EmpCo law; do not treat the separate proposal as an enacted requirement.
Which one should my marketing team plan around now?
Plan around the enacted national EmpCo measures in your markets. The EU application deadline was 27 September 2026, but national enactment and commencement need checking. Do not delay claims audits while waiting for the Green Claims proposal; the Commission announced its withdrawal on 4 November 2026, and evidence files remain essential under EmpCo and existing consumer law.
When will the Green Claims Directive apply?
Most likely never. The Commission announced on 4 November 2026 that it will withdraw the proposal within six months. There is no application date, and you should not plan for its requirements.
Does the Green Claims Directive replace EmpCo?
No. The proposal was designed to sit alongside EmpCo as an up-front evidence and verification regime. With its withdrawal announced on 4 November 2026, EmpCo and existing consumer law are the rules that apply. The withdrawal does not affect EmpCo.

More answers on the FAQ page, and definitions in the glossary.